THE TALES OF MARK, LUKE AND MATTHEW

Introduction
Federico Carra, lawyer and scholar of Eastern cultures, decided to resume his studies after the death of his father, hoping to understand whether they might meet again one day. After many years of research, notes, and drafts, he found himself with enough material for a book—and with the long-sought answer.
The book examines the texts of the Gospels of Mark, Luke, and Matthew, which are called the Synoptic Gospels because they can be read side by side, allowing their many similarities to be immediately seen. Jesus was Jewish and spoke and preached in Aramaic, but all the Gospels are written in Greek. This linguistic leap brought with it a cultural and mental shift that altered—and in some cases erased—the original Jewish context.
The book explores all of this with the aim of introducing readers to Judaism and Palestine in the time of Jesus, taking into account the complex political, religious, and linguistic circumstances. The Gospel narratives are analyzed within this framework. The conclusions that emerge may be surprising.
In the overview of religious texts, there is generally a consistent methodology and religious attitude (in terms of faith and orthodoxy) among their authors. This work, however, does not follow the traditional methods of New Testament exegesis. Instead, it adopts the approach pioneered by Baruch Spinoza and other independent thinkers, which consists of applying basic logic to the analysis of the texts, supported by a broad and in-depth knowledge of the subject matter.
The book
The work is a commentary on the three Synoptic Gospels—in other words, the Gospels that share material that can be read comparatively. Despite the parallels, the three Gospels are distinct and reflect the different geographical origins, native languages, the different eras in which their authors lived, and the different theological ideas underlying the three accounts. The term “tales” indicates that not everything the Gospels narrate is true, and is used here because the authors, who wrote several decades after Jesus’ death, also reported facts and words incompatible with the Jewish beliefs and customs of the time. Of particular importance is the linguistic issue: Jesus spoke Aramaic, while the Synoptic Gospels were written in Greek. This linguistic leap also entails a cultural leap, that is, the adoption of a Greco-Hellenistic ideology and the abandonment of a Jewish one. The book, therefore, takes into account the context of both its origin and its destination.
Table of Contents
PREFACE
READING NOTES
CHAPTER I – PALESTINE AND JESUS
CHAPTER II – THE QUESTION OF LANGUAGE, PART I
CHAPTER III – THE SYNOPTIC QUESTION
CHAPTER IV – THEMES OF THE GOSPELS
CHAPTER V – THE GOSPEL ACCORDING TO MARK
CHAPTER VI – THE GOSPEL ACCORDING TO LUKE
CHAPTER VII – THE GOSPEL ACCORDING TO MATTHEW
CHAPTER VIII – THE QUESTION OF LANGUAGE, PART II
CHAPTER IX – THEOLOGICAL REFLECTIONS
APPENDIX – PEOPLE OR CHARACTERS? PETER, ISRAEL, JESUS, PAUL
BIBLIOGRAPHY
GENERAL WORKS
SPECIALIZED WORKS
Press release
Bibliography + Links
Bibliography
- A. Antiseri & G. Reale, Storia della filosofia greca dalle origini ad oggi, Bompiani, Milan 2009
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, Libreria Editrice Vaticana, Rome 1992
- Herodotus (edited by L. Rossetti), Histories, Newton Compton, Rome 2013
- W.D. Davies & L. Finkelstein, The Cambridge History of Judaism, Cambridge University Press 2008
- Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, Città Nuova 2015
- Flavius Josephus (edited by G. Vitucci), The Jewish War, Fondazione Lorenzo Valla, 2009
- Photius (edited by N. Wilson), Bibliotheca, Adelphi, Milan 1992
- Flavius Josephus (edited by L. Moraldi), Jewish Antiquities, De Agostini, Novara 2013
- Justin Martyr (edited by G. Visonà), Dialogue with Trypho, Paoline, Milan 1988
- Irenaeus of Lyon (edited by Enzo Bellini), Against Heresies and Other Writings, Jaca Book, Milan 1997
- M. Liverani, Antico Oriente, in Storia Universale, vol. 3, RCS Quotidiani, Milan 2004
- J. Neusner, A.J. Avery-Peck & W.S. Green, The Encyclopaedia of Judaism, Brill, Leiden 2005
- Homer (trans. by G. Paduano), Iliad, Einaudi-Gallimard, Turin 1997
- Homer (trans. by R. Calzecchi Onesti), Odyssey, Einaudi, Turin 2005
- M. Pesce (ed.), Le parole dimenticate di Gesù, Fondazione Lorenzo Valla, 2009
- E. Prinzivalli & M. Simonetti, Seguendo Gesù. Testi cristiani delle origini, Fondazione Lorenzo Valla, 2010
- P. Ricca, Chiave biblica, Claudiana, Turin 2009 B. Russell, History of Western Philosophy, TEA under license from Longanesi, Milan 1948
- J.A. Soggin, , Paideia, Brescia 2002
- L. Sorel, Dictionnaire du paganisme grec, Les Belles Lettres, Paris 2015
- H.L. Strack & P. Billerbeck, Kommentar zum Neuen Testament aus Talmud und Midrasch, Beck, Munich 1926
Specialized Works
- AA. VV., Nuovo grande commentario biblico, Queriniana, Brescia 2002
- A. VV., The critical edition of Q, Peeters 2000
- AA. VV, Il mondo degli apocrifi, San Paolo, Milan 2010
- A-C. Avril e P. Lehnhardt, La lettura ebraica della Scrittura, Qiqajon, Magnano (BI) 1984
- J. Barr, Old and new in interpretation, SCM Press Ltd.1966
- G.K.Beale e D.A Carson, L’antico Testamento nel Nuovo, Paideia, Brescia 2017
- M.E. Boring, Introduzione al Nuovo Testamento, Paideia, Brescia 2016
- F. Bovon, Vangelo di Luca, Paideia, Brescia 2005
- R.E. Brown, Introduzione al Nuovo Testamento, Queriniana, Brescia 2001
- R. Bultmann, Teologia del Nuovo Testamento, Queriniana, Brescia 2008
- Casey M., An Aramaic Approach to Q, Cambridge University Press 2002
- C. Cohn, Processo e morte di Gesù da un punto di vista ebraico, Einaudi, Torino 2000
- M. Craveri (ed.), I Vangeli Apocrifi, Einaudi, Torino 2005
- B. Corsani, I Vangeli sinottici, Claudiana, Brescia 2008
- P. De Benedetti, La morte di Mosè, Morcelliana, Brescia 2005
- P. De Benedetti, Quale Gesù, Morcelliana, Brescia 2014
- P. De Benedetti, L’alfabeto ebraico, Morcelliana, Brescia 2011
- P. De Benedetti, Introduzione al giudaismo, Morcelliana, Brescia 2009
- J.D.G. Dunn, Dal vangelo ai Vangeli, San Paolo, Milan 2012
- J.D.G Dunn, Christianity in the Making, Jesus remembered, W. B. Eerdmans Pub. Co. 2003
- J. Jeremias, Le parole dell’ultima cena, Paideia, Brescia 1973
- I. Finkelstein e N.A. Silberman, Le tracce di Mosè, Carocci, Roma 2002
- J.A. Fitzmyer, A wandering Aramean, Scholars Press Chico, California 1979
- C. Freeman, Sacre reliquie. Dalle origini del Cristianesimo alla Controriforma, Einaudi, Torino 2012
- C. Freeman, Il Cristianesimo Primitivo, Einaudi, Torino 2010
- C. Giannotto, Pietro, Il Mulino, Bologna 2018
- G. Garbini, Il vangelo aramaico di Matteo, Paideia, Brescia 2017
- G. Garbini, Scrivere la storia di Israele, Paideia, Brescia 2008
- G. Garbini, Vita e mito di Gesù, Paideia, Brescia 2015
M. Grilli, Vangeli sinottici e Atti degli apostoli, EDB, Bologna 2016 - M. Grilli, Una bibbia due testamenti, San Paolo, Milano 2010
- M. Grosso, Vangelo secondo Tommaso, Carocci, Roma 2011
- N.A Knibb e E. Ullendorf, The ethiopic Book of Enoch, Oxford University Press 1978
- P. Lehnhardt, L’unità del dio trinitario, Glossa, Milano 2016
- M. Liverani, Oriente Occidente, Laterza, Bari 2021
- M. Liverani,Oltre la bibbia, Laterza, Bari 2003
- J.B. Lumpkin, The Books of Enoch, Fifth Estate Publishers 2009
- U. Luz, 2002 Matteo, Paideia 2006
- D. Marguerat (ed.), Introduzione al Nuovo testamento, Claudiana, Torino 2004
- A. Mello, Evangelo secondo Matteo, Qiqajon, Magnano (BI) 1995
- W.A. Meeks, 2006 Cristo è il problema, Paideia, Torino 2017
- V. Messori, Ipotesi su Gesù, Edisioni Ares, Milano 2019
- S.A. Missick, The words of Jesus in the original aramaic, Xulon press 2006
- L. Moraldi (ed.), I manoscritti di Qumrān, UTET, Novara 2013
- J. Neusner, Un rabbino parla con Gesù, San Paolo, Milano 2007
- J. Neusner e B. D. Chilton, In Quest of the Historical Pharisees, Baylor University Press 2007
- P. Odifreddi, Perché non possiamo essere cristiani, TEA su licenza Longanesi, Milano 2007
- P. Odifreddi, Diavolo e acquasanta a confronto sulla sindone, in Micromega 4/2010
- A. Pincherle, Introduzione al Cristianesimo antico, Laterza Bari 1971
- E. Prinzivalli e M. Simonetti, La teologia degli antichi cristiani, Morcelliana, Brescia 2012
- L. Quercioli Mincer, 101 Storie ebraiche, Newton Compton, Roma 2011
J. Ratzinger,Gesù di Nazareth, Rizzoli, Milano 2007 - G. Rizzi, Le antiche versioni della Bibbia, San Paolo, Milano 2009
- P. Sacchi, Apocrifi dell’Antico Testamento, UTET, Torino 1981
- R. Simone, Fondamenti di linguistica, Laterza, Bari 1995
- T. Soeding e C. Muench, 2005 Breve metodologia del Nuovo Testamento, Paideia, Brescia 2018
- G. Theissen e A. Merz, Il Gesù storico, Queriniana, Brescia 2011
- G. Vermes, The religion of Jesus the Jew, 1Fortress Press 1993
- G. Vermes, The complete Dead Sea scrolls, Penguin Books 1962
- G. Vermes, Jesus der Jude, Neukirchner Verlag d. E., Neukirchen-Vluyn 1993
- A. Yarbro Collins, Marco, Paideia, Brescia 2018
Links
SEFARIA (“Biblioteca”)
la libreria di tutti i testi sacri ebraici e della letteratura rabbinica
https://www.sefaria.org/texts
JEWISH ENCYCLOPEDIA
la storica enciclopedia giudaica in inglese del 1901-1906
https://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/
BIBLE HUB
Portale con il testo multilingue della Bibbia e molteplici risorse (lexicon, atlante, commenti, testi interlineari, ecc.)
https://biblehub.com/
Il sito ufficiale dei rotoli del Mar Morto
https://www.deadseascrolls.org.il/
https://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/
The unedited full- text of the 1906 Jewish encyclopedia
https://www.sefaria.org/ A Living Library of Torah
https://www.deadseascrolls.org.il/ Digital Library
https://www.bibbiaedu.it/ Chiesa Cattolica Italiana
https://biblehub.com/ Online bible Study Suite
Buy your copy
© 2025 Federico Carra. All rights reserved to the author..